Rodney wrote:Not having the VHS myself, I can't speak to the other damage -- but VHS-era transfers often had a considerably cropped frame, losing some of the edge of the image in order to make sure no frame edges were visible on your TV. This would also have cropped off places where the sprocket holes have intruded into the image area. Recent transfers tend to be more edge-to-edge, which gives you all the available image, perhaps including intrusive sprocket holes.
Also, the softness of VHS transfers may reduce the number of noticeable specks and lines, which (along with the detail you want) become more apparent in BluRay.
Then again, maybe it's just that the source material is a couple of decades older...
In a film theater, the edges of the screen are masked with black cloth to make them sharp, a practice you could adapt to your home theater
I plan to order the Blu-ray edition of LES VAMPIRES soon, and welcome a transfer that includes as much of the image as possible. Visible sprocket holes on the edges, while slightly distracting, are to some extent also an enjoyable film artifact. Our last local theatre that runs real 35mm film plans to switch to completely digital sometime in October. I tend to watch all movies on16mm film, DVD, or Blu-ray projected in my home theatre, so I can simply pull in my side black velvet masking to cover up the sprocket hole if they become too annoying. Of course if you watch on a TV set, you're stuck with them unless you set it to underscan the picture and lose image information all around.
