Jim Roots wrote:Good lord! Neibaur's churning them out like a dupe factory in China these days! What's this, his third book in less than 18 months or something?
Jim
This is what Mr. Neibaur said about it at another board:
"As with my books on Buster Keaton or Charlie Chaplin, I feel that the major comedians can not be well served with just a broad overview of their entire career. Most of you know that I have done books on Keaton's talkies, Keaton's films with Arbuckle, Chaplin's Essanays, and Chaplin's Keystones. I am currently doing one on Keaton's silent shorts, and will follow up with one on Charley Chase's talkie shorts (at Roach and Columbia).
"So, my Langdon book is not a bio or a filmography. It is a film-by-film look at his silent movies, discussing their significance and making a serious case for greater appreciation, especially those films he directed himself (their negative reputation has to be quashed)."
As one of the authors who has just completed a "broad overview" of Harry Langdon, I strongly disagree that he "can not be well served" by it, especially since our work uncovers so many neglected or poorly researched aspects of his career. But most of the major clowns are the subjects of several books (sometimes several DOZEN books), and if anyone deserves the same level of attention, it's Langdon.
Michael J. Hayde