I expect a certain amount of dislike based on change, which will fade as people get used to it. But here's how we got here. We
had to upgrade to PhpBB 3 or our hosting company would drop us because we were too insecure; we brought their whole server down twice when spammers exploited the weaknesses of PhpBB 2. That part was non-negotiable.
Initially I tried to find someone who would build a replica of 2 as close as possible. It wasn't even that it was going to cost a lot, though it probably would have, but that no one wanted to do it. Apparently the way PhpBB works is that new themes are mostly built on top of the basic code for
ProSilver, which is the name for the hideous blue theme a few people saw briefly. And our look was just too different to be easily imitated.
So then I went shopping for something that at least had the same monochrome virtues as the old NitrateVille.
This is the basic theme we started with. I had it tailored to a NitrateVille look and had a live demo that the moderators were able to test over the weekend, but really, there's no substitute for everyone using the real thing. So, use it, discover new things it offers and old things you liked it doesn't offer, provide feedback, and we can continue to evolve it. But this is where we are, and have to be.