Fri Jun 27, 2008 2:59 pm
You are correct, Strawberry Blonde. Yes, the original play and the 1933 movie are quite noirish-- the setup is that the Cagney character (Gary Cooper in the original) is a dentist contemplating murdering his romantic rival by dialing up his anesthesia, and recalling his past history with the gal who got away as he decides whether or not to do it! Somehow without actually removing that aspect of the plot, Raoul Walsh and company make it a much more cheerful piece about a lovable lunkhead who thinks he wishes he married Rita Hayworth but actually is much better off with Olivia deHavilland. (Him and Ashley Wilkes both.) It's one of Cagney's best performances and I think that whole run of late 30s/early 40s Walsh pictures at Warners is a string of unsung gems-- Roaring Twenties, High Sierra, They Drive By Night, Gentleman Jim, Manpower....
We should respect the other fellow's religion, but only to the extent that we respect his theory that his wife is attractive and his children intelligent. —H.L. Mencken