Harlett O'Dowd wrote:But ultimately, Nitrateville probably isn't the place to have this discussion. Bob, is there any way of bringing up this subject at the business meeting this year?
Well, this does come up for discusion every year, and the answer, as I noted to Chris elsewhere, is always the same. We need a banquet, NOT because we love to have a banquet but because the hotel demands the revenue. Also, at least one of our committee people--and the most valuable one during the show, because she coordinates all the volunteers, just LOVES the banquet.
We also place these celebrity screenings of later films strategically so that those who aren't interested in the film or the guest will be driven to the dealers rooms. The dealers are a major component of the show. We're in the theater, they're in the hotel--you figure it out.
As for rare titles, I think Cinecon through the years has shown more rare titles than any of the other festivals, if you look at the schedule this year, I think you'll find quite a few films that most of the attendees will not have seen, and (unless they live near New York, L.A. or Rochester) would not likely get a chance to see on a theater screen, among such rareties this year are:
TRIAL MARRIAGE (never scrrened anywhere before Cinecon 45)
Love Detectives (Pre-Code; Betty Grable short)
HE FELL IN LOVE WITH HIS WIFE (screened at UCLA preservation festival where about 50 people attended)
BROADWAY LOVE
GIVE OUT, SISTERS (where are you going to see this in 35mm?)
PAID TO LOVE
TRICK FOR TRICK (last time it was screened in L.A. was 18 years ago when we ran it)
GOOD TIME CHARLEY
Screen Snapshot (1923, Clara Bow)
THE DAWN OF A TOMORROW
NIGHTMARE (1942)
TURN TO THE RIGHT!
LOVER COME BACK (1931)
DE LUXE ANNIE
So at least half the schedule is stuff that either hasn't been screened or is not likely to be screened anywhere else, and I daresay that even most of the more "common" titles like "Easy Living" or "Rumba" or "The Bride Comes Home" are films that most of our attendees will not have seen previously.
I always cite the example of Charlie Chaplin's "The Circus," which we ran in the small room back when we were at the Red Lion in Glendale while we ran an incredibly rare Tiffany in the big room. 12 people sat to watch the Tiffany--over a hudred crammed into the small room and we had to turn people away. Most of these people, good Cinephiles all, had never seen "The Circus" even though it had been in continuous distribution theatrically, non-theatrically, on cable, on Super 8mm and on video for about twenty years. Not all the Cinecon attendees are as "well screened" as we are.
And, strangely enough, they want to be entertained. About six years ago we had a schedule that pushed rarety over entertainment--and, boy did I get an earful--literally surrounded by about 20 people at 6:00 pm Monday evening--all complaining that rare was all well and fgood, but thy paid their money to be entertained.
Yes, years ago, we did do some celebs in the Cinegrill or other small rooms-and even though that worked then, it won't now. Our star wrangler demands a screening or feels we are not showing enough respect. This is the same star wrangler we had fifteen years ago--but things change. Cinecon, like life, is a compromise. We need to attempt to satisfy all of us who put it on and all of the attendees sitting in the dark. It ain't easy stepping through that minefield, believe me.
In any event there was a time when there were as many as fifteen celebrity events during Cinecon. This year there are three celeb screenings, and one honoree who is only coming to the banquet. So, as the crop of golden age celebs has dwindled, we've also cut back on the number of celeb appearances. And, I have to tell you that the only questions regarding the schedule that I've received through the web site e-mail are: When will "The Silencers" and "Easy Living" be screened?