Page 1 of 1

ID Request/Quiz on a silent comedy film

Posted: Thu Dec 29, 2016 10:56 am
by JFK
JFK wrote:1. I have a wild idea as to the identity of the tattered, taller player
in the blurry second image below that I found on the internet.
2. Guess the name of anyone you think the taller player might be
3. Are you done guessing?
I reveal my own guess below in tiny (05) white typeface-
the same sort of "spy typeface" Putin uses when sending Trump valentines.
Merely click the "quote" button to read my tortured reasoning.
......My eyes aren't so good, but could John Wayne have made a film (see image below)
in the summer of 1924, while still attending Glendale High School ?
Excerpt: Wikipedia Glendale High School Entry
"The school continued to grow, as enrollment reached 800 in 1920 and 1,050 in 1921.
It was decided then to move the Grade 10, 11 and 12 classes to a new campus at the corner of the present-day Broadway Avenue and Verdugo Road (Grade 9 students remained at the Maryland Street campus, and were later integrated into area Middle Schools). The school has remained in this location (1440 East Broadway, at the southeast corner of Verdugo) since 1924." "The large weights and sizes of the players in the 1924-1925 American football team, with all of the starting 11 players weighing 170 pounds or more and with almost all of them six or more feet tall, made them, in the words of the authors of Duke: The Life and Times of John Wayne, "a high school phenomenon"."

Mermaid Comedies had a studio on Verdugo Road in Glendale (at least they did in 1922) and of course Wayne showed up in a Norman Taurog short, The Draw Back (1927), a few years later.
Click image for a larger version which you should then click again for slightly better results
which, at the very least, prove me goofy
....
Image
Image
R Michael Pyle wrote:If we didn't write this, how do we hit an "edit" button?
Oops Thanks I meant hit the "quote" button-
I have now corrected my initial post

Re: ID Request/Quiz on a silent comedy film

Posted: Thu Dec 29, 2016 11:53 am
by R Michael Pyle
If we didn't write this, how do we hit an "edit" button?

ID Request/Quiz on a silent comedy film

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 10:51 pm
by JFK
Click the image below for a larger version, which you should then click again for even more gigantic results
Image

Re: ID Request/Quiz on a silent comedy film

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2017 11:47 pm
by odinthor
Carefully not revealing anything: Certainly, among other indications, the shadow under his cheekbone matches that in another pic I find...

Re: ID Request/Quiz on a silent comedy film

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 8:59 am
by LouieD
No way. Not him in any way.

ID Request/Quiz on a silent comedy film

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 10:59 am
by JFK
While the (anonymous) polling remains open - early indicators suggest I am, once again, full of- if not positively overflowing with- hooey.
And thus, my dream of obtaining this lobby card cheaply, and then re-selling it for millions, is quickly fading, leaving behind only the bitter taste of nitrate ashes in my mouth.
And yet..... even if my football-playing-actor identification is rejected by the voters, I do have another "unidentified actor" guess to throw into the mix... I'm now suggesting -with somewhat less confidence- that the mysterious man grasping the tall football player is none other than film funnyman Kevin Hart.

Re: ID Request/Quiz on a silent comedy film

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2017 4:00 pm
by Tommie Hicks
I do know who one of the persons in the picture is, he is Harry Thaw. Lige Conley was 5'2". Harry Thaw was only a couple of inches higher.

Image

The unknown man in the pic is not tall enough to be the pilgrim proclaimer of cinema legend. My guess is Charlie Phillips.