Post
by CoffeeDan » Tue Nov 08, 2011 1:07 am
I think everybody's missing the real reason that story suffers in today's films. The markets for good stories have all but dried up in the last 50 years.
We tend to forget that what we now call the "studio era" coincided with a great renaissance in the publishing industry around the turn of the last century. The stories and serials of the popular weeklies and monthlies like The Saturday Evening Post, Collier's, Liberty, The Cosmopolitan, The American Magazine, Everybody's Magazine, McClure's, Harper's, Esquire, and Redbook -- as well as the cheaper "all-story" pulp magazines like Argosy, Blue Book, and Black Mask -- soon became fodder for the movies. Look carefully at the credits in most films from 1920-60, and chances are they were adapted from a short story or serial that first appeared in the popular press.
In my research on Liberty magazine, I found that the following movies were based on stories or serials appearing in its pages:
THE SHOCK PUNCH (1925)
THE STREET OF FORGOTTEN MEN (1925)
BRIGHT LIGHTS (1925)
MANNEQUIN (1926)
LOVE'S GREATEST MISTAKE (1927)
THE SMALL BACHELOR (1927)
WALKING BACK (1928)
WHITE PANTS WILLIE (1928)
SHOW GIRL (1928)
DANCE HALL (1929)
THE GREAT GABBO (1929)
FOR THE LOVE O' LIL (1930)
MURDERS ON THE ROOF (1930)
SHOW GIRL IN HOLLYWOOD (1930)
CORSAIR (1931)
HEARTBREAK (1931)
NIGHT NURSE (1931)
THE LAST FLIGHT (1931)
THE LOST SQUADRON (1932)
TORCH SINGER (1933)
CHANCE AT HEAVEN (1933)
THE CIRCUS QUEEN MURDER (1933)
THE WOMAN ACCUSED (1933)
HI, NELLIE! (1934)
SADIE McKEE (1934)
WOMAN IN THE DARK (1934)
THE PRESIDENT'S MYSTERY (1936)
MY MAN GODFREY (1936)
BIG BROWN EYES (1936)
SERGEANT YORK (1941)
YANKEE DOODLE DANDY (1942)
DOUBLE INDEMNITY (1944)
DESTINATION TOKYO (1945)
FRANCIS (1950)
THE MAN WITH MY FACE (1951)
THE HARDER THEY FALL (1956)
This is but a partial list -- one article I read says that over 120 movies had their beginnings in the pages of Liberty. Multiply that times the number of magazines publishing popular fiction in those days, and you see what an important source they were for the movie industry back in the studio era.
But starting in the 1950s, the companies who advertised in the popular press began spending more money on TV advertising, and gradually, the great general interest magazines fell by the wayside. Liberty folded in 1951, The American went under in 1956, Collier's in 1957, and The Saturday Evening Post -- which had the longest publishing history of any magazine at the time -- closed in 1969 after 148 years of publication (before it was revived as a quarterly in 1971, and continues to this day as a bi-monthly). These were some of the best markets for up-and-coming writers of fiction to showcase their works.
In addition, many magazines stopped publishing fiction altogether and concentrate only on nonfiction today. One of the best fiction showcases, Redbook, stopped publishing stories about 10 years ago. While it was and is commited to publish the best fiction from new and established writers, The Atlantic Monthly has cut back its offerings in recent years. About the only magazine that manages to publish as much fiction as it did in its heyday and continue to maintain its high standards is The New Yorker.
With the popular weeklies and monthlies gone, many writers turned to TV to sell their stories, and the various television markets (including the internet) continue to be the movie industry's greatest competitors. So it doesn't surprise me to see so many movies that are adaptations of TV shows, because it's mainly TV that now "publishes" the kind of stories and serial entertainment that used to be popular in print in prior generations.
Last edited by
CoffeeDan on Wed Feb 12, 2020 12:28 am, edited 11 times in total.