Post
by sethb » Tue May 03, 2011 5:19 pm
I was fortunate to see SHOW GIRL IN HOLLYWOOD on TCM (but it's also available from Warner Archive for those who didn't).
It's interesting to compare this with BROADWAY MELODY. I thought that despite some obvious technical limitations, SHOW GIRL was very well done, with a fair amount of moving camerawork and even some insert shorts (which were likely shot silent and cut in later, perhaps?).
Even though BROADWAY MELODY may have more gloss, I always thought it was pretty leaden from a plot and dialogue standpoint. And that's where SHOW GIRL shines, IMO. There's the cute bit about the sign painter continually scraping names off office doors as folks become "just a memory" at the studio, and the bit with all the "yes men" around the studio exec.
But the best dialogue comes when Alice White is asked by a lecherous director to attend a private dinner-for-two at his house, where her new contract would supposedly be waiting for her. In response she says "I'm suspicious of contracts that aren't signed in the daytime" (Joe Breen would have been proud!). Unfortunately, although Alice had lovely eyes, nice legs and a decent high kick, that was about it -- an actress she wasn't. I've seen better delivery of lines by UPS.
Very cute movie though, and a nice slice of Vitaphone history to boot in the "I've Got My Eyes on You" number, with the studio orch right on the set and the camera sweatboxes all set up.
Incidentally, the final number looks like it may originally have been shot in two-strip Technicolor, because the present b&w rendition looks a bit dupey. Can anyone supply any information about this? SETH
Please don't call the occasional theatrical release of an old movie a "reissue." We do not say "The next time you go to the Louvre, you will see a re-issue of the Mona Lisa.” -- Cecil B. DeMille